Shepherd Product Manager Interview Guide

Getting ready for a Product Manager interview at Shepherd? The Shepherd Product Manager interview process typically spans strategic product thinking, data-driven decision making, cross-functional collaboration, and customer-centric problem solving. At Shepherd, interview preparation is especially important because the company is pioneering technology-driven solutions for commercial insurance, requiring Product Managers to expertly balance technical innovation with intuitive user experiences for clients in complex, high-risk industries.

In preparing for the interview, you should:

• Understand the core skills necessary for Product Manager positions at Shepherd.
• Gain insights into Shepherd’s Product Manager interview structure and process.
• Practice real Shepherd Product Manager interview questions to sharpen your performance.

At Interview Query, we regularly analyze interview experience data shared by candidates. This guide uses that data to provide an overview of the Shepherd Product Manager interview process, along with sample questions and preparation tips tailored to help you succeed.

Shepherd is an insurtech company focused on transforming risk management for commercial businesses, starting with the $10 trillion commercial construction industry. By combining top-tier insurance products with advanced SaaS solutions, Shepherd helps clients manage risk, prevent losses, and streamline underwriting workflows. The company leverages technology and novel data sources to enable faster, more accurate underwriting and incentivizes clients to adopt best-in-class tools. As a Product Manager, you will play a central role in shaping Shepherd’s platform and driving innovation that improves outcomes for high-hazard businesses. Shepherd is backed by leading venture capital firms and operates out of San Francisco, New York, and Dallas Fort Worth.

As a Product Manager at Shepherd, you will drive the end-to-end planning, development, and execution of innovative insurance technology products for the commercial construction industry. You’ll collaborate closely with cross-functional teams—including engineering, underwriting, finance, customer experience, and operations—to gather requirements, define product vision, and prioritize features that streamline workflows and enhance risk management. Your role involves building intuitive solutions for complex processes, leveraging customer feedback, and presenting product updates to senior leadership. By maintaining the product roadmap and delivering data-driven insights, you help ensure Shepherd’s platform remains competitive and supports the company’s mission to transform commercial insurance through technology.

2.1 Stage 1: Application & Resume Review

The interview process begins with a thorough review of your application and resume, focusing on your experience with end-to-end product planning and execution, especially within SaaS, insurtech, fintech, or other highly regulated industries. The team looks for evidence of a strong track record in prioritizing product requirements, collaborating cross-functionally, and delivering data-driven insights. It’s essential that your resume clearly demonstrates your ability to break down complex problems, communicate effectively with diverse stakeholders, and drive product initiatives from ideation through launch. To prepare, ensure your application highlights relevant leadership, technical, and customer-centric achievements.

2.2 Stage 2: Recruiter Screen

Next, you’ll have an initial conversation with a Shepherd recruiter, typically lasting 30–45 minutes. This call is designed to assess your motivation for joining Shepherd, alignment with the company’s mission, and overall fit for the Product Manager role. Expect to discuss your background, why you’re interested in Shepherd, and your approach to product management in fast-paced, high-growth environments. Preparation should focus on articulating your passion for building intuitive, user-friendly products, and your experience collaborating with engineering, design, and business teams.

2.3 Stage 3: Technical/Case/Skills Round

In this round, you’ll meet with the CTO and co-founder, as well as other technical team members. The focus here is on evaluating your product sense, problem-solving ability, and technical aptitude through case studies and scenario-based questions. You may be asked to design dashboards (e.g., for merchant or sales performance), model user segmentation for SaaS products, propose metrics for product success, or outline experiments to validate product ideas. Demonstrating familiarity with SQL, BI tools, and data-driven decision-making is key. Preparation should involve practicing structured approaches to product design, articulating trade-offs, and explaining how you would gather and prioritize requirements.

2.4 Stage 4: Behavioral Interview

This stage typically involves conversations with cross-functional team members from engineering, operations, customer experience, or finance. The aim is to assess your collaboration skills, leadership style, and ability to communicate complex ideas. You’ll be asked to share examples of exceeding expectations, navigating ambiguous situations, and influencing stakeholders. Be ready to discuss how you’ve handled challenging product launches, incorporated customer feedback, and balanced competing priorities. Preparation should include reflecting on your leadership experiences and how you foster alignment across teams.

2.5 Stage 5: Final/Onsite Round

The final round is an onsite visit at Shepherd’s San Francisco HQ, where you’ll meet with a broader set of stakeholders, including potential peers and senior leadership. This stage often includes a mix of product deep-dives, whiteboard exercises, and culture-fit interviews. You may be asked to present a product roadmap, walk through your approach to prioritizing features, or demonstrate your ability to simplify complex workflows for non-technical users. Prepare to showcase your strategic thinking, customer empathy, and ability to drive alignment in high-stakes settings.

2.6 Stage 6: Offer & Negotiation

If successful, you’ll enter the offer and negotiation phase, typically led by the recruiter. This stage covers compensation, benefits, start date, and any final questions about the role or company culture. Shepherd is known for offering competitive healthcare, professional development, and flexible PTO, so be prepared to discuss your expectations and any unique needs.

2.7 Average Timeline

The typical Shepherd Product Manager interview process spans 3–4 weeks from initial application to final offer, with each stage generally taking about a week. Fast-track candidates—especially those with strong insurtech, SaaS, or startup backgrounds—may complete the process in as little as 2–3 weeks, while standard pacing allows for more time between rounds to accommodate scheduling and onsite coordination. The onsite round is usually scheduled promptly after successful completion of virtual interviews.

Now that you understand the process, let’s dive into the types of interview questions you can expect at each stage.

3.1 Product Strategy & Metrics

Product managers at Shepherd are expected to make data-driven decisions, define and track key metrics, and design experiments that directly impact business outcomes. These questions test your ability to evaluate the impact of new features, promotions, or operational changes, and articulate the reasoning behind your recommendations.

3.1.1 You work as a data scientist for ride-sharing company. An executive asks how you would evaluate whether a 50% rider discount promotion is a good or bad idea? How would you implement it? What metrics would you track?
To answer, outline an experimental design (A/B test or pre/post analysis), specify primary metrics (e.g., conversion rate, retention, LTV, margin impact), and discuss potential risks or confounders. Frame your answer around balancing short-term growth with sustainable economics.

3.1.2 How to model merchant acquisition in a new market?
Describe the data sources and models you'd use to forecast acquisition, suggest segmentation or cohort analysis, and explain how you’d validate assumptions. Emphasize the importance of identifying leading indicators and iterating based on early learnings.

3.1.3 Design a dashboard that provides personalized insights, sales forecasts, and inventory recommendations for shop owners based on their transaction history, seasonal trends, and customer behavior.
Explain your process for requirements gathering, prioritizing actionable metrics, and wireframing. Discuss how personalization and predictive analytics would be incorporated to drive business value for end users.

3.1.4 How would you design user segments for a SaaS trial nurture campaign and decide how many to create?
Walk through segmentation logic (demographic, behavioral, or value-based), the criteria for determining segment granularity, and how you’d test and iterate on the segments’ effectiveness.

3.1.5 Which metrics and visualizations would you prioritize for a CEO-facing dashboard during a major rider acquisition campaign?
Highlight your approach to identifying high-level KPIs, ensuring real-time accuracy, and tailoring the dashboard for executive decision-making.

3.2 Experimentation & Analysis

This category evaluates your ability to design and interpret experiments, assess causality, and use insights to guide product decisions. Shepherd values PMs who can balance rigor with speed and communicate findings clearly.

3.2.1 The role of A/B testing in measuring the success rate of an analytics experiment
Describe why A/B testing is effective, how you’d set up control and treatment groups, and which success metrics are most relevant. Mention how to interpret results and act on them.

3.2.2 How would you identify supply and demand mismatch in a ride sharing market place?
Lay out your approach to data collection, analysis of temporal and spatial patterns, and the metrics that indicate imbalance. Suggest possible interventions and how you’d measure their effectiveness.

3.2.3 Building a model to predict if a driver on Uber will accept a ride request or not
Discuss feature selection, model choice, and evaluation criteria. Highlight how you’d use the model’s predictions to inform product or operational changes.

3.2.4 Experimental rewards system and ways to improve it
Explain how you’d structure experiments to test new rewards, select metrics to track engagement or cost, and iterate based on results.

3.2.5 How would you measure the success of an email campaign?
List the key metrics (open rate, CTR, conversion, unsubscribe), how you’d attribute impact, and what you’d do with the findings to optimize future campaigns.

3.3 Data Architecture & Product Analytics

Shepherd PMs need to understand the technical underpinnings of their products and how to leverage data infrastructure for better insights. These questions assess your ability to design scalable analytics and reporting systems.

3.3.1 Design a data warehouse for a new online retailer
Describe your approach to schema design, data sources, ETL processes, and how the warehouse would support analytics and reporting needs.

3.3.2 Designing a dynamic sales dashboard to track McDonald's branch performance in real-time
Explain your process for selecting metrics, ensuring data freshness, and building intuitive visualizations for operational users.

3.3.3 What kind of analysis would you conduct to recommend changes to the UI?
Discuss using funnel analysis, cohort analysis, and user feedback to identify pain points and opportunities for improvement.

3.3.4 Making data-driven insights actionable for those without technical expertise
Describe how you’d tailor communication, use visuals, and focus on business impact to ensure stakeholders understand and act on insights.

3.3.5 How to present complex data insights with clarity and adaptability tailored to a specific audience
Share your approach to storytelling with data, adjusting your narrative and visuals depending on the audience’s background and needs.

3.4 Behavioral Questions

3.4.1 Tell me about a time you used data to make a decision that led to a measurable business outcome.
Explain the context, the data analysis you performed, and how your recommendation influenced strategy or operations.

3.4.2 Describe a challenging data project and how you handled it.
Discuss the obstacles you faced, your approach to problem-solving, and what you learned from the experience.

3.4.3 How do you handle unclear requirements or ambiguity in a product or analytics project?
Share your strategies for clarifying goals, aligning stakeholders, and iterating towards clarity.

3.4.4 Tell me about a time when your colleagues didn’t agree with your approach. What did you do to bring them into the conversation and address their concerns?
Highlight your communication, empathy, and collaboration skills in resolving disagreements.

3.4.5 Walk us through how you handled conflicting KPI definitions (e.g., “active user”) between two teams and arrived at a single source of truth.
Describe your process for negotiating, standardizing, and documenting KPIs to ensure alignment.

3.4.6 Give an example of how you balanced short-term wins with long-term data integrity when pressured to ship a dashboard quickly.
Discuss the trade-offs you made and how you communicated risks or limitations.

3.4.7 Share a story where you used data prototypes or wireframes to align stakeholders with very different visions of the final deliverable.
Explain how visualizations or early prototypes helped bridge gaps in understanding.

3.4.8 Describe how you prioritized backlog items when multiple executives marked their requests as “high priority.”
Detail your prioritization framework and how you communicated decisions transparently.

3.4.9 Tell us about a time you caught an error in your analysis after sharing results. What did you do next?
Emphasize your accountability, how you corrected the issue, and steps you took to prevent recurrence.

3.4.10 How have you balanced speed versus rigor when leadership needed a “directional” answer by tomorrow?
Describe your triage process and how you communicated uncertainty or caveats while still enabling timely decisions.

4.1 Company-specific tips:

Familiarize yourself with Shepherd’s mission to modernize commercial insurance for high-risk industries, especially construction. Understand how Shepherd integrates advanced SaaS solutions with insurance products to streamline underwriting and risk management workflows. Review recent press releases, product launches, and case studies to grasp the company’s approach to leveraging technology and novel data sources for better client outcomes. Be ready to discuss how Shepherd’s platform differentiates itself in the insurtech space and why you’re passionate about contributing to its vision.

Demonstrate an understanding of the challenges faced by commercial construction businesses, such as risk prevention, claims management, and regulatory compliance. Prepare to speak about how product innovation can solve pain points unique to these clients. Show your appreciation for Shepherd’s focus on incentivizing best-in-class tool adoption and how this strategy drives measurable improvements for their customers.

Research Shepherd’s leadership team, investors, and company culture. Be ready to articulate why you align with their values and how your background fits into a fast-paced, venture-backed startup environment. Highlight your adaptability and eagerness to work across offices in San Francisco, New York, or Dallas Fort Worth.

4.2 Role-specific tips:

4.2.1 Prepare to demonstrate strategic product thinking and data-driven decision making.
Expect to answer questions about designing dashboards, modeling user segmentation, and proposing product metrics. Practice structuring your responses to case studies by clearly outlining your approach, prioritizing actionable insights, and explaining trade-offs. Be ready to discuss how you would use data to validate product ideas and measure success, especially in scenarios involving merchant acquisition, SaaS trial campaigns, or rider promotions.

4.2.2 Highlight your cross-functional collaboration skills.
Gather examples from your experience where you worked closely with engineering, underwriting, operations, and customer experience teams. In your stories, emphasize how you facilitated alignment, managed competing priorities, and drove consensus on product requirements. Be prepared to discuss how you navigate ambiguity, clarify unclear requirements, and foster productive relationships across diverse stakeholders.

4.2.3 Showcase your ability to build intuitive solutions for complex workflows.
Shepherd’s products serve clients with sophisticated needs and high stakes, so practice communicating how you simplify complex processes through thoughtful product design. Prepare to walk through how you gather requirements, wireframe dashboards, and tailor user experiences for both technical and non-technical audiences. Use examples that demonstrate your empathy for the customer and your commitment to usability.

4.2.4 Be ready to discuss experimentation and product analytics.
Expect to be tested on your understanding of A/B testing, cohort analysis, and KPI selection. Prepare to describe how you design experiments, interpret results, and iterate on product features based on data. Use real examples to illustrate your skills in measuring campaign success, identifying supply-demand mismatches, and making data-driven recommendations for UI changes or rewards systems.

4.2.5 Practice communicating complex insights clearly and persuasively.
Shepherd values PMs who can translate technical findings into actionable business recommendations. Prepare to present complex data in simple terms, using storytelling and visuals tailored to executive, operational, or customer audiences. Be ready to share how you’ve handled situations where you needed to correct errors, standardize KPI definitions, or balance speed with rigor in delivering insights.

4.2.6 Prepare examples of prioritization and stakeholder management.
Think through how you’ve managed backlog prioritization, especially when faced with conflicting requests from executives. Be ready to share your decision-making frameworks and how you communicate trade-offs transparently. Highlight your ability to balance short-term wins with long-term product integrity, and describe your approach to negotiating alignment on strategic priorities.

4.2.7 Reflect on your leadership style and adaptability.
Consider stories that showcase your ability to exceed expectations, influence teams, and thrive in ambiguous or high-pressure environments. Shepherd is looking for PMs who can lead by example, adapt quickly to change, and inspire cross-functional teams to deliver innovative products. Be genuine about your growth mindset and how you learn from challenges or setbacks.

5.1 How hard is the Shepherd Product Manager interview?
The Shepherd Product Manager interview is considered challenging and highly selective, particularly for candidates without prior insurtech or SaaS experience. The process emphasizes strategic product thinking, technical acumen, and the ability to collaborate across diverse teams. You’ll be expected to tackle complex case studies, articulate data-driven decisions, and demonstrate a deep understanding of risk management in commercial insurance. Success hinges on your ability to blend innovative product vision with practical execution in a fast-paced, high-stakes environment.

5.2 How many interview rounds does Shepherd have for Product Manager?
Candidates typically go through five main rounds: Application & Resume Review, Recruiter Screen, Technical/Case/Skills Round, Behavioral Interview, and a Final/Onsite Round. Each stage is designed to assess a distinct set of skills, from strategic thinking and technical problem-solving to cross-functional collaboration and culture fit. Some candidates may also participate in an offer and negotiation stage following the onsite interviews.

5.3 Does Shepherd ask for take-home assignments for Product Manager?
While take-home assignments are not guaranteed, candidates may be asked to complete a product case study or analytical exercise, especially in the technical or skills round. These assignments often involve designing dashboards, modeling user segmentation, or proposing product metrics. The goal is to evaluate your structured thinking and ability to solve real-world product challenges relevant to Shepherd’s business.

5.4 What skills are required for the Shepherd Product Manager?
Shepherd seeks Product Managers with a strong foundation in product strategy, data analytics, and cross-functional leadership. Key skills include:
- Strategic product planning and roadmap development
- Experience with SaaS or insurtech products
- Data-driven decision making (SQL, BI tools, experimentation)
- Customer-centric problem solving
- Stakeholder management and communication
- Ability to simplify complex workflows and drive innovation
- Familiarity with risk management or regulated industries is a plus

5.5 How long does the Shepherd Product Manager hiring process take?
The Shepherd Product Manager interview process typically takes 3–4 weeks from initial application to final offer. Fast-track candidates may complete all rounds in as little as 2–3 weeks, while standard pacing allows for more time between interviews and coordination of the onsite round.

5.6 What types of questions are asked in the Shepherd Product Manager interview?
Expect a mix of strategic, technical, and behavioral questions. You’ll encounter product case studies (e.g., dashboard design, merchant acquisition modeling), data analytics challenges (e.g., experimentation, KPI selection), and scenario-based questions about collaboration and leadership. Behavioral interviews focus on your ability to navigate ambiguity, influence stakeholders, and drive alignment across teams.

5.7 Does Shepherd give feedback after the Product Manager interview?
Shepherd typically provides high-level feedback through the recruiting team, especially for candidates who reach the later stages of the process. While detailed technical feedback may be limited, you can expect constructive insights into your fit for the role and areas for improvement.

5.8 What is the acceptance rate for Shepherd Product Manager applicants?
While Shepherd does not disclose specific acceptance rates, the Product Manager role is highly competitive due to the company’s rapid growth and focus on innovation in commercial insurance. An estimated 3–5% of qualified applicants advance to the offer stage.

5.9 Does Shepherd hire remote Product Manager positions?
Shepherd offers flexibility in work arrangements, including remote Product Manager positions. However, some roles may require occasional travel to offices in San Francisco, New York, or Dallas Fort Worth for team collaboration and onsite meetings. Be prepared to discuss your preferences and adaptability during the interview process.

• Related guides:
  • Shepherd interview questions
  • Product Manager interview guide
  • Top product management interview tips

Ready to ace your Shepherd Product Manager interview? It’s not just about knowing the technical skills—you need to think like a Shepherd Product Manager, solve problems under pressure, and connect your expertise to real business impact. That’s where Interview Query comes in with company-specific learning paths, mock interviews, and curated question banks tailored toward roles at Shepherd and similar companies.

With resources like the Shepherd Product Manager Interview Guide and our latest case study practice sets, you’ll get access to real interview questions, detailed walkthroughs, and coaching support designed to boost both your technical skills and domain intuition.

Take the next step—explore more case study questions, try mock interviews, and browse targeted prep materials on Interview Query. Bookmark this guide or share it with peers prepping for similar roles. It could be the difference between applying and offering. You’ve got this!